Showing posts with label class warfare. Show all posts
Showing posts with label class warfare. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 7, 2012

The Righteous Amongst Billionaires




In recent years Warren Buffett has joined the ranks of George Soros as a “righteous” billionaire to millions of frantic Obama supporters preaching wealth redistribution. In his old age, Mr. Buffett has supported raising taxes on the wealthiest Americans who tend to pay lower tax rates than many middle-class citizens. Time and time again Mr. Buffett has pointed out that he does not pay enough taxes. Without trying to dissect whether his contention has merit, it is clear to me that Mr. Buffett’s demonstrative actions to emphasize his point have been quite hypocritical.

Tired of hearing of Mr. Buffett’s low tax rate, many of his detractors have suggested that Mr. Buffett voluntarily send a check to the U.S. government for the conceived shortfall. However, Mr. Buffet dismissed this request for unilateral action and instead offered to match any similar donations by Republican members of Congress. It appears that Mr. Buffett is only willing to do the right thing if others join him in action. This is akin to saying “stealing is horrible and completely reprehensible, but I will not stop stealing unless everyone else also stops.”

Recently, several media outlets have glorified Mr. Buffett for living up to his pledge when he matched Rep. Scott Rigell’s (VA-R) donation of $49,000 to the U.S. government (15% of Rigell's Congressional Salary). The media was awash with praise of Mr. Buffett, yet many such articles ignored a very simple incongruity. If Mr. Buffett believes that he should pay the same percentage of taxes as other Americans, why is he simply matching the dollar amount of Rep. Rigell’s donation? If Mr. Buffett truly wanted to be “fair” (according to his own definition), he would not merely match the dollar amount of Rep. Rigell’s donation, but he would prorate the donation to reflect his significantly higher level of income and net worth. Of course that would mean millions upon millions of dollars, not a measly $49,000 which to Mr. Buffet is like a quarter under the couch cushion.

I don’t know what is motivating Mr. Buffett’s call to action, perhaps it’s a feeling of guilt that stems from a lifetime of financial success (he has amassed a fortune of nearly $40 billion). Maybe it is the desire to leave a positive legacy in the twilight of his life. Regardless of what this driving force might be, it’s unfortunate that Mr. Buffett is only willing to take a stand at the expense of others who do not agree with him. If Mr. Buffett acts as a leader and does the right thing, as he has done with his philanthropic organizations, without asking the same of others, he will earn the positive legacy that he appears to seek.

Saturday, May 23, 2009

My trip to Europe

As I am writing this post I have not slept for 30 hours. I thought I'd share with you some of my impressions of the UK over the last day. Here is the recap of my day. Upon arriving at London Heathrow I knew I had to make my way to the London Paddington train station to catch my train to Bristol (my final destination in the UK). To get from Heathrow to Paddington I boarded an express train, and with a little help from a co-worker I managed to score a first class seat for this 15 minute journey. What did the first class ticket provide besides charging most people double the regular fare? I would say absolutely nothing. I could not understand who in their right mind would pay an additional 20 dollars to sit in the first class car, and yet there were three other passengers in the first class. And then I realized, I'm in Europe. Unlike the US, class tensions have dominated political and social discourse on the content for the over a millianea. Here there are distinct differences between the son of an aristocrat and the average joe's kid. For all of Europe's idealism and self-righteousness this simple example illustrates that the in Europe class warfare is a much more significant topic than in the United States. Where in the United States would you see passengers split out between the haves and the have nots on a fifteen minute journey?