Thursday, September 18, 2008

What's up with Russia?

As many of you have probably heard the Russian market has experienced quite a decline recently. The decline in the Russian market is only outdone by the Chinese stock markets. The decline stems from the fall in oil and commodity prices, drop in the demand from China, and the fall of the ruble.

But what is lost in all of this is the effect of a certain Mr. Putin and his politics. It seems to me that Putin believes that he can bring back the old Soviet Union, but what he doesn't understand is that the current Russia is much more intertwined into the world economy than the Soviet Union ever was. This is precisely why his authoritarian tendencies are really hurting the Russian economy.

For instance, what investor will feel comfortable when even large companies such as BP cannot escape the grasps of the government. The track record of Yukos, Mechel, already painted a dim picture of the Russian rule of law, but the past Georgian war has really hurt.

Now I'm not defending Russia or Georgia, but the fact that this war drove a sharp decline in foreign investment is evidence of irresponsible leadership. Somehow I highly doubt that China with all of its authoritarianism would be willing to start a war with a foreign country or Taiwan. That is because when a regime is already viewed as shaky and potentially unfriendly to foreign business, something as dubious as a war with a tiny neighbor isn't going to do much for investor confidence.

In the end it appears that Russia might come to realization that the economy and not Georgia should be its primary focus. I don't exactly see how adding two tiny and impoverished republics to its territory, should be the government's priority. If Russia remains ignorant of such realities, it risks economic collapse which is likely to bring about a regime change that even Mr. Putin won't be able to avoid. Russia must make a choice capitalism and rule of law or authoritarianism and murky economics.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Hey, i like the blog,

As much as I dislike Putin, from the time he came into office to about May this year, the Russian economy has grown strongly. Even if you take the current russian stock market index which i think is less than half of its May high, and annualize the return since 2000,it's still a very high return.

---"For instance, what investor will feel comfortable when even large companies such as BP cannot escape the grasps of the government. "--
Until Russia runs out of it's resources that it sells to europe and whoever else, this is not going to be that large of a concern. While foreign investment is nice, a mountain of foreign cash in exchange for your oil/gas is even better. What's europe going to do if it's offended? Not buy russian oil and gas? There would be riots in every city in europe if russia cut supplies.

Most importantly, the war in Georgia had nothing to do with Russia's wish to help minorities in Georgia or it's hate of Georgia. The Kosovo independence had been the last straw for russia, in terms of seeing the nato/eu powers dictating what will happen in every area around russia. Georgia was a good choice for Russia to attack and show that it will not have eu/nato allies/operations on every side of it. Georgia was and is a very strategic area for EU/Nato. This is because of the two pipelines that run through georgia, one going to a turkish port and the other to a georgian port and eventually to europe. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan_pipeline http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baku-Supsa_Pipeline
If it wasn't for these pipelines, this war wouldn't have even showed up on american news channels :)

Any way, don't know where i'm going with this. Long story short, Putin's goal is to regain some of russia's power, not to create a 'nice' country to live in for the prolitariate, and not to attract foreign investment at the expense of russia's influence.

some youtube stuff about btc
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0pi-GdkEu8Q
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5-YBIxvd_ng (start at 2:00)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3QW6zTZNaLc